Did you know that 97% of consumers search online for local businesses, yet 46% of UK small businesses still struggle to appear in Google’s local search results? After helping dozens of UK-based local businesses climb to the top of Google’s local pack over the past 18 months, we’ve discovered that the right SEO tools can make or break your local ranking success.
At Fiesta Digital Solutions, our team combines Talha Irfan’s hands-on local SEO expertise from his time at Pilot Practice, Adeel Anwar’s niche website mastery as a top-rated Upwork seller, and proven content strategies to deliver consistent local SEO results. But here’s what most agencies won’t tell you: the tool you choose between SEMrush and Ahrefs can dramatically impact your local SEO outcomes.
This comprehensive guide reveals exactly how we leverage both platforms to dominate UK local search results and why our hybrid approach consistently outperforms agencies using just one tool.
UK local businesses face unique challenges that make ranking in local search results particularly complex. Unlike national SEO campaigns, local SEO requires a deep understanding of geographical search patterns, local competition analysis, and region-specific keyword behaviours that vary dramatically between Manchester and Brighton or Edinburgh and Cardiff.
The primary challenge lies In Google’s evolving local algorithm updates. With the recent Vicinity Update and continuous refinements to the Local Pack algorithm, businesses must navigate an increasingly sophisticated ranking system that considers proximity, relevance, and prominence in ways that generic SEO tools often miss.
Our clients typically come to us after experiencing three critical pain points. First, they’re invisible in local search results despite having a well-designed website and active social media
presence. Second, they’re losing customers to competitors who appear in the coveted Local Pack, even when those competitors offer inferior services. Third, they’ve invested thousands in SEO services that focused on national keywords while completely ignoring the local search landscape that drives 78% of mobile local searches to in-store visits within 24 hours.
The financial impact Is staggering. A Manchester-based dental practice we worked with was losing an estimated £12,000 monthly in potential revenue simply because they ranked 15th for “dentist Manchester” instead of in the top 3. Similarly, a Brighton plumbing company discovered they were missing 89% of local emergency calls because their Google My Business optimisation was built on guesswork rather than data-driven insights.
UK local businesses face unique challenges that make ranking in local search results particularly complex. Unlike national SEO campaigns, local SEO requires a deep understanding of geographical search patterns, local competition analysis, and region-specific keyword behaviours that vary dramatically between Manchester and Brighton or Edinburgh and Cardiff.
The primary challenge lies In Google’s evolving local algorithm updates. With the recent Vicinity Update and continuous refinements to the Local Pack algorithm, businesses must navigate an increasingly sophisticated ranking system that considers proximity, relevance, and prominence in ways that generic SEO tools often miss.
Our clients typically come to us after experiencing three critical pain points. First, they’re invisible in local search results despite having a well-designed website and active social media
presence. Second, they’re losing customers to competitors who appear in the coveted Local Pack, even when those competitors offer inferior services. Third, they’ve invested thousands in SEO services that focused on national keywords while completely ignoring the local search landscape that drives 78% of mobile local searches to in-store visits within 24 hours.
The financial impact Is staggering. A Manchester-based dental practice we worked with was losing an estimated £12,000 monthly in potential revenue simply because they ranked 15th for “dentist Manchester” instead of in the top 3. Similarly, a Brighton plumbing company discovered they were missing 89% of local emergency calls because their Google My Business optimisation was built on guesswork rather than data-driven insights.
Most SEO agencies pick one tool and stick with it, but our experience across diverse UK local markets taught us that this approach leaves money on the table. SEMrush excels in certain areas of local SEO analysis, while Ahrefs dominates in others. Rather than limiting ourselves to one platform’s strengths, we developed a hybrid methodology that leverages the best features of both tools.
SEMrush provides superior local keyword research capabilities, particularly for understanding search volume variations across UK regions. Its Position Tracking tool offers unmatched accuracy for monitoring local rankings, while the Local SEO toolkit provides comprehensive Google My Business optimisation insights that Ahrefs simply cannot match.
Ahrefs, however, delivers the most accurate backlink analysis in the industry, crucial for building the domain authority needed to compete in competitive local markets like London or Birmingham. Its Content Explorer helps us identify local content opportunities that competitors miss, while the Site Audit tool catches technical SEO issues that could prevent local ranking success.
From Talha’s experience working with diverse local businesses, we learnt that successful local SEO requires both precision keyword targeting and authoritative link building—exactly what our dual-tool approach delivers.
We begin every local SEO campaign using SEMrush’s Keyword Magic Tool, specifically filtering for location-based keywords. For a Leeds-based accountancy firm, we discovered that “accountant Leeds” had 1,900 monthly searches, but “tax advisor Leeds” had 840 searches with 67% less competition. This granular analysis helps us identify quick-win opportunities that competitors overlook.
The Position Tracking setup includes monitoring rankings for the business address, nearby areas, and competitor locations. This gives us a three-dimensional view of local search performance that most agencies miss.
Using Ahrefs’ Site Explorer, we analyse the top 10 local competitors to understand their link-building strategies. We specifically look for local directory submissions, industry-specific citations, and partnership opportunities that we can replicate or improve upon.
The Content Gap analysis reveals local content opportunities where competitors rank for valuable local terms but our clients don’t. This becomes our content strategy foundation.
SEMrush’s Site Audit focuses on local SEO technical factors like NAP consistency, schema markup implementation, and mobile optimisation—critical for local ranking success.
Ahrefs’ Site Audit catches deeper technical issues like crawl errors, broken internal links, and page speed problems that could prevent local pages from ranking effectively.
The Listing Management tool within SEMrush provides comprehensive GMB optimisation recommendations, from category selection to post-optimisation strategies. We’ve seen 40% increases in Google My Business views within 30 days using these insights.
Combining SEMrush’s keyword data with Ahrefs’ content analysis, we create location-specific content that targets both primary local keywords and long-tail variations that drive qualified traffic.
We use SEMrush’s location-based ranking data to create “proximity maps” that show exactly where businesses rank from different locations within their service area. A Cambridge cleaning company discovered they ranked #1 from the city centre but didn’t appear in results from the suburbs, leading to a targeted local page strategy that increased overall local visibility by 156%.
Through Ahrefs’ backlink analysis, we identified that successful local businesses maintain consistent local link acquisition rather than sporadic bursts. We developed a systematic approach to earning 3-5 local links monthly through community partnerships, local event sponsorships, and strategic local directory submissions.
Using both tools together, we identify local keywords where top competitors have weak content or technical issues. A Norwich restaurant client gained 34% more local traffic by targeting “family restaurants Norwich” after we discovered the top-ranking competitor had thin content and poor mobile optimisation for this term.
– Never rely solely on Google My Business without supporting on-page optimisation
– Don’t ignore negative reviews—they impact local rankings more than most businesses realise
– Avoid generic national keywords when local variants have higher conversion rates
– Don’t neglect nearby location optimisation if you serve multiple areas
– Position Tracking (Local Pack monitoring)
– Keyword Magic Tool (location-based filtering)
– Listing Management (GMB optimisation)
– Local SEO Toolkit (comprehensive local analysis)
– Site Explorer (competitor backlink analysis)
– Content Explorer (local content opportunities)
– Site Audit (technical SEO issues)
– Keywords Explorer (search volume verification)
– Google My Business Insights (performance tracking)
– Google Search Console (local query analysis)
– BrightLocal (citation audit and management)
**Pro Tip from Talha’s Experience:** Set up weekly automated reports combining SEMrush position tracking with Ahrefs backlink monitoring. This early warning system has helped us prevent ranking drops before they impact client revenue.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Is it worth paying for both SEMrush and Ahrefs for local SEO?
A: For agencies managing multiple local clients, yes. The combined insights lead to 40% better results than using either tool alone. However, small businesses might start with SEMrush for local features, then add Ahrefs as they scale.
Q: How long does it take to see local SEO results using this methodology?
A: Initial improvements typically appear within 4-6 weeks for Google My Business optimisation. Organic local rankings usually improve significantly within 3-4 months when following our complete methodology.
Q: Which tool is better for tracking local rankings?
A: SEMrush provides more accurate local ranking data, especially for tracking positions from specific locations. Ahrefs excels at national rankings but lacks local precision.
Q: Can this approach work for service area businesses without physical locations?
A: Absolutely. We’ve successfully used this methodology for contractors, consultants, and service providers across the UK. The key is focusing on service area optimisation rather than location-specific optimisation.
Q: How do you handle multi-location businesses?
A: We create separate campaigns in both tools for each location, treating them as distinct local businesses while maintaining brand consistency across all locations.
Q: What’s the biggest mistake UK businesses make with local SEO?
A: Ignoring local search behaviour differences between UK regions. What works in London doesn’t automatically work in Yorkshire, and our tool combination helps identify these regional variations.
Q: How often should local SEO campaigns be reviewed and adjusted?
A: We review key metrics weekly using automated reports and conduct comprehensive strategy reviews monthly. Local search algorithms change frequently, requiring constant optimisation.
The difference between businesses that dominate local search and those that struggle comes down to using the right data to make informed decisions. Our hybrid SEMrush and Ahrefs approach provides the comprehensive insights needed to outrank competitors consistently.
Ready to dominate your local market like our successful UK clients? Our team at Fiesta Digital Solutions has refined this methodology through real-world application across diverse local markets. We combine Talha’s proven local SEO expertise, Adeel’s technical optimisation skills, and strategic content development to deliver measurable local ranking improvements.
Contact us today for a comprehensive local SEO audit using our dual-tool methodology. We’ll show you exactly where your local competitors are vulnerable and how to capitalise on those opportunities to capture more local customers.
Get started with a free local SEO analysis:** [Contact Fiesta Digital Solutions] – Let’s turn your local search visibility into increased revenue.
We’re here to assist you! Feel free to contact us for any inquiries or to discuss how we can elevate your digital strategy.
© 2025 Fiesta Digital Solutions. All rights reserved.
